More meetings and lots more food for thought. Continue reading
Jet-lag grabbed me this morning. In the afternoon, while rain flooded some areas of São Paulo, I read and made notes on Brian Wampler‘s Participatory budgeting in Brazil: contestation, cooperation and accountability. This book examines PB in 8 Brazilian cities, including São Paulo, but was published in 2007. A few things have happened since then…
I spent most of today working on a presentation. One of our partners, Leandro Ramos, has contacted the relevant department of São Paulo’s city administration. It turns out they are very keen to hear how participatory budgeting (PB) works in Scotland. This is great, because
- I’m involved in setting up and running this year’s LeithChooses PB process, and so can speak from some experience of how a small group of dedicated, unpaid volunteers are working together to run and improved version of a civic process.
- We can hear from some people who know how PB in São Paulo really works.
|#||When||What||outcome and notes|
|1||July||RIVAL: community event on the theme of LIS research impact:||success!
Also enabled further funding application (line 5)
|2||July||applying for GCRF funding for PB in Brazil||success!
See line 7
|3||July||marking work-based learning 2017-18 final reports||——-|
|4||September||Drafting an idea for some public engagement/democracy work||to revisit in 2019|
|5||September||RSE funding application to follow up RIVaL: RIVaL network||success!
Work to start in Feb 2019
|6||October||marking work-based learning 2018-19 initial reports||——-|
|7||October to present||PB in Brazil: whether and how PB benefits the very poor in Sao Paulo Bruce going to Sao Paulo 4 to 27 Jan, Wegene 4 to 13 Jan||LitRev in progress
builds on CSI’s relationship with University of Sao Paulo
|8||November||marking BSAD coursework 1||——-|
|9||November||application for RIO funding to run WriteNow! writing sessions in 2019||success!
working with Frances
|10||December||marking work-based learning 2018-19 mid-year reports||——-|
|11||December||marking BSAD coursework 2||——-|
Could I offer a short course or other help to students’ improve their report-writing skills?
|12||July||contribution to 2018 Digital Governance in Municipalities Worldwide: A Longitudinal Assessment of Municipal Websites Throughout the World||fancy certificate of thanks|
|13||July to present||minuting meetings between Community Councils Together on Trams and Edinburgh Council’s Trams Team||better citizen-involvement?|
|14||September||Taking part in a follow-up to research by the Scottish Community Development Centre on community councils.||led to involvement in draft PB charter|
|15||September to present||member of £eith Chooses steering group||voting Saturday 23 February 2019|
|16||October, November||further participation in Scottish Government (SG) Online Identity Assurance stakeholder group||TBC|
|17||November||participation in debate/research on governance of and possible new powers for community councils||TBC|
|18||December||commenting on Scottish Government draft Open Government Action Plan||appreciated by SG|
|19||December||participation in Scottish Government/CoSLA event on mainstreaming participatory budgeting. Write-up of event is in a set of posts starting here||TBC|
|20||all year||minutes and websites for three Edinburgh community councils:||better recording and publicising of hyperlocal government activities|
The content of these posts has now been moved here: https://bruceryan.info/resources/mainstreaming-participatory-budgeting-event
Individual pages can be accessed via these links:
- Tweets of anticipation and excitement
- Welcome and overview of the day: Oliver Escobar
- The Scottish context – local governance review and public service reform: Professor James Mitchell
- Evidence to date: Dr Angela O’Hagan
- Q&A with James Mitchell and Angela O’Hagan
- Examples of PB mainstreaming
- Group discussions: Mainstreaming PB is a transformation, not a process. What do we need to do to ensure it is a success? Anthony Zacharzewski (Democratic Society)
- What is needed for councils [and other public bodies] to transform internally?
- What is needed for communities to be ready to participate?
- What us needed to create strong and trusted processes and spaces?
- Plenary session: Way forward: what will we commit to get from here to our ambition?
(Tweets from this item are in the previous section.)
- Closing remarks: Claire McPherson (Scottish Government)
Following on from my last post about Online Identity Assurance, this post is to draw attention to a couple of posts on the Scottish Government Digital blog:
- Online Identity Assurance – Collaborating through OIX
- Online Identity Assurance – Thank you stakeholders
I’m pleased to see in the first of these posts
The first stream will be about developing two end-to-end journeys, taken by people using services, that can be shown to work as a ‘proof of concept’. One will centre on the process of applying for a Child Disability Living Allowance – a benefit that will become the responsibility of the new Scottish social security system in 2020 – with the other relating to the process of applying for the single occupant Council Tax deduction offered by local authorities.
because that implies to me that SG is taking a sensible ‘suck it and see’ approach, rather than trying for a Big Bang that ends up full of issues.
And here’s looking forward to more interesting developments in 2019!
Being involved, no matter how tangentially, with the Scottish Government’s work on online identity assurance (OIA) is important to me for at least five reasons.
- I want government to be efficient, and that means using digital techniques when possible and rational.
- While pursuing that aim, government must pay great heed to privacy and security. This is mostly because government has (in theory) great power to do good and do harm. (NB I do not believe that the current SG intends to do harm.)
- There will always be people who cannot use digital techniques. This may be because they don’t know how just now. This may be because they will always lack the mental capacity to know how. This may be because they do not wish to learn how: either they see nothing in it for them, or the potential gains are not worth the time and money outlays for them. And of course it may be because they don’t have a roof over their heads, let alone expensive internet devices.
- I’m a social informatics researcher, so anything in the interfaces between IT and society interests me.
- My particular research niche is IT in hyperlocal democracy, and there are explicit links between identity and the right to vote.
For the 3rd event (31 March), I used a different tactic – I live-tweeted as well as I could, then collected tweets and other snippets using Wakelet. (This is a successor to Storify, recommended by the fab Leah Lockhart on advice from Ross McCulloch.)
So, so long as Wakelet permits it, my OIA wakelet is here. Comments are very welcome!
This post is inspired by my taking part in the Open Rights Group (Scotland)‘s e-voting round-table in February, and the Scottish Government’s Online Identity Assurance‘show and tell’ in March, and by a seminar by Professor Brian Detlor last week. (My notes from the ORG’s round-table should be available on the Open Government Network website. I’ve also posted them on my personal blog.) In this post, I assume that e-voting would be run on central servers, but votes would be cast via software running on personal phones, tablets and computers. Continue reading
This post is my digital record of the Scottish Government’s Online Identity Assurance (OLA) ‘show and tell’. The day was very informative, and provided me the opportunity to catch up with friends in civil society circles. I’m especially interested because online identity is a natural precursor to online voting, another problematic area that greatly interests me.
The post starts with a recap of what was said at the event, then notes my input at the event. Next are my reactions to the event itself, followed by my thoughts on the whole OLA programme. In summary, while I think OLA is very worthwhile, and that the Scottish Government is trying to do it the right way, I have a lot of reservations about how useful it will be for those who most need government support.